The world’s biggest supplier of burgers sourced meat from a farmer in the Amazon who had been found guilty of using deforested land, say reports.
Marfrig, a Brazilian meat company that has supplied McDonald’s, Burger King and other fast-food chains around the world, bought cattle from a farm that had been using deforested land earlier this year, according to a joint investigation by Repórter Brasil and the Bureau of Investigative Journalism.
The company said it was misled by a government certificate that cleared the farm of deforestation, and it has since ended the association. Marfrig has recently launched an environment “transition bond” to tap into the growing sustainable investment market.
In January, inspectors from Ibama, Brazil’s environmental watchdog, found cattle from Limeira Ranch grazing on illegally deforested land inside a protected region, the Triunfo do Xingu environmental protection area in Pará state. The region has been devastated by forest fires this year.
The part of the farm where the cattle were found had been placed under an official embargo – which prohibits grazing – three years before, due to illegal felling. Embargos are imposed for environmental violations and serve both as a punishment and protective measure to allow land to recover.
For breaking the embargo, the ranch was fined 1.19m reais (£236,000) this year. Despite this, documents obtained by Repórter Brasil show that 144 cattle from Limeira Ranch were subsequently supplied to a Marfrig abattoir in Tucumã, in Pará. The company also bought cattle from the ranch on multiple occasions in late 2018. There is no evidence that the cattle Marfrig purchased were themselves raised on illegally deforested land.
Marfrig told the Guardian: “On the date of purchase, February 16, 2019, Marfrig’s geo-monitoring platform collected all available information about the supplier … At that date … there was no record of non-compliance. It was not on the Ibama embargoed producers list, there was no satellite detection of deforestation in the area and the rancher was not on the official list of companies using slave-like labour.
“Ibama issued a negative certificate assuring that on that date … nothing was against the supplier. And that’s the only way companies – not just Marfrig – can look for official information in real time. From the moment the official inclusion information was made available by Ibama, the supplier (and so in any and all cases) was automatically and immediately blocked. This means that, since then, rancher Adriano José de Mattos and Fazenda Limeira cannot supply Marfrig.” Marfrig supplied the Ibama certificate clearing the ranch as part of their reply.
The Bureau has established, using trade data and shipping records, the extent of the links between Brazilian meat companies and the UK. Nearly £1bn worth of beef supplied by three of the meat giants – Marfrig, JBS and Minerva and their subsidiaries – was directly imported to the UK in the past five years.
Much of this supplied major UK supermarkets, as well as wholesalers and independent food companies.
Meanwhile new figures released by Trase, a supply-chain initiative run by the Stockholm Environment Institute and NGO Global Canopy, delineate the deforestation risks in the export supply chains of three of Brazil’s major beef companies, including Marfrig. The Trase research mapped supply chains for beef from international markets back through customs and slaughterhouses to the municipalities where cattle were raised, using customs, agricultural, and sanitary inspection data.
Having traced the cattle back to their original municipalities, Trase cross-referenced government figures on cattle numbers with deforestation data and official data on new pastures to calculate a deforestation “risk” – presented as an area in sq km – associated with companies and specific international markets.
The analysis includes data on “indirect” suppliers, which are often intermediate farms that don’t sell directly to abattoirs, but supply other farms that may truck cattle to slaughter.
According to Trase’s calculations, Marfrig’s beef exports come from farms linked to up to 100 sq km of deforestation risk a year in Brazil. Trase also calculated figures for JBS, the world’s biggest meat company, and Minerva Foods, another large global supplier of Brazilian beef. JBS beef exports have been linked to farms involved in up to 300 sq km of deforestation risk per year, and Minerva Foods linked to farms involved in 100 sq km of risk, according to the research.
Marfrig said: “It would be a mistake to conclude from Trase data that there is a link between the cattle purchased by Marfrig and deforestation in the region. Precisely because it understands that there is a risk and that Trase information provides relevant services for the preservation of biomes, Marfrig developed and implemented its geo-monitoring platform. This system is audited by an independent third party – Norwegian DNV GL. Using this platform and analysing Trase information, Marfrig substantially mitigates the risk of acquiring animals from deforestation – using, since 2009, the zero deforestation criterion for the Amazon biome.”
Minerva said: “Sustainability forms one of the fundamental pillars of Minerva Foods, at its core to feed the world, conserve the planet and enhance human value … 100% of Minerva’s purchases come from zero-deforestation areas in the Amazon biome. Overlapping our suppliers’ ranch map with deforestation polygons, indigenous lands and environmental protection areas, our sustainability department blocks any supplier that are not compliant with any of the criteria, which effectively means that Minerva can’t buy any animals coming from these suppliers.”
JBS said: “JBS has an unwavering commitment to combat, discourage and eliminate deforestation in the Amazon region … For nearly a decade, we have monitored our supply chain with satellite technology, geo-referenced farm data and official government records to ensure compliance with our stringent responsible sourcing policies … The most recent audit in 2018, conducted by DNV GL, a global quality assurance and certification company based in Norway, confirmed that 100% of our cattle purchases were in compliance with our responsible sourcing policies.”
Burger King told us: “Our goal is to eliminate deforestation within our global supply chain, and we are working toward this.” They said that all their suppliers were required to comply with their sustainability and forest protection policies.
McDonald’s said it aimed to eliminate deforestation from its global supply chains by 2030 and that it had “made a commitment not to purchase raw material from any farm in the Amazon … linked with deforestation”.
This July Marfrig launched a $500m “transition” bond. Like “green bonds”, which allow environmentally friendly firms to raise cash, bankers have designed transition bonds for companies with the potential to clean up their practices to fund that change. In the bond framework, the company states: “Our vision is to be recognised as the best global protein company. This will happen with commitment to sustainability.”
Original source: www.theguardian.com